ARTICLE · PSYCHOLOGY · 15 MIN READ
ARE WE REALLY FREE, OR IS IT ALL AN ILLUSION?
I have often wondered what it really means to be free.Not the kind of freedom we talk about when someone asks for permission and we say, “Yo

I have often wondered what it really means to be free.
Not the kind of freedom we talk about when someone asks for permission and we say, “You are free to go.” Not the freedom written into constitutions, promised during political campaigns, or celebrated on Independence Day.
I mean something much more personal.
The freedom to choose.
The freedom to decide.
The freedom to say, “This is my life, and this is what I want to do with it.”
We like to believe that we have that freedom. In fact, most of us hardly question it. Every day, we make choices. We decide what to wear, what to eat, who to talk to, what to study, where to go, what to believe and, sometimes, what kind of future we want for ourselves. We stand at crossroads and choose one direction instead of another.
And because we were the ones who made the decision, we conclude that we are free.
But are we?
Let me ask you something.
Before you made the choices that have shaped your life, did you choose the person who would make those choices?
Did you choose your parents?
Your country?
Your family?
Your genes?
Your childhood?
Your culture?
The answer is no.
And yet, somehow, all these things have had a hand in shaping the person you are today, the very person who now believes they are freely choosing. Especially our family. Take me, for example. I may try to be rebellious, but I know deep in my mind that I am not stupid enough to do certain things in my life, even with a gun on my head, because I would first of all think about my family's reaction to it. Especially my mother. It's funny, but it's true.
And that is where my problem with the idea of absolute free will begins.
I do not think we are completely free.
I think we are free, perhaps, in the way a person is free to move around a room whose walls they did not build.
We can walk.
We can turn.
We can sit in one corner or stand in another.
But we did not choose the room.
The Things That Choose Before We Do
We often speak about choices as though they appear from nowhere.
As though one morning, we wake up as completely independent human beings and simply decide what we want.
But think about your life for a moment.
Why do you want the things you want?
Why do you fear the things you fear?
Why do some people desperately want success while others are terrified of standing out?
Why does one person see marriage as a dream while another sees it as something to escape?
Why do some people remain in situations that hurt them while others leave?
We often say, “That is just who they are.”
But who decided who they would be?
From the moment we are born, we begin absorbing the world around us. Before we are old enough to question anything, we are already being taught what is normal, what is shameful, what is desirable and what is possible.
Our families influence us.
Our cultures influence us.
Our experiences influence us.
Our societies influence us.
Even the things that hurt us influence us.
A child raised in a loving and secure home may grow up seeing the world differently from a child raised in fear. Someone who has experienced poverty may make decisions that a wealthy person may never understand. Someone who has been constantly criticised may spend their entire life chasing approval without even realising it.
So when they finally make a choice, can we honestly say that they made it independently of everything that came before?
This is the heart of determinism: the idea that our actions may be the result of causes that existed before the action itself.
Our genes influence our temperaments. Our upbringing shapes our beliefs. Our environment affects our opportunities. Our past experiences create our fears and desires. One event leads to another, which influences another, which shapes another decision.
And eventually, somewhere at the end of this long chain, we say:
“I chose.”
But did we?
Or did everything that happened before us quietly participate in the decision?
Perhaps the problem is that we think being influenced and being controlled are two completely different things. Sometimes they are. But where exactly does influence end and control begin?
Could You Really Have Chosen Otherwise?
This is the question that unsettles me the most.
Take one important decision you have made in your life.
Now imagine going back to that exact moment.
Nothing changes.
You have the same memories.
The same personality.
The same fears.
The same desires.
The same information.
The same circumstances.
Everything is exactly as it was.
Would you genuinely make a different choice?
And if you would, why?
What would make you suddenly choose differently if absolutely nothing about you or the situation had changed?
This is where free will becomes complicated.
Every decision we make seems to come from something: a reason, a desire, a fear, a belief, an experience, a value.
But where did those things come from?
You may say, “I chose this because I wanted it.”
Fair enough.
But did you choose what you wanted?
You may say, “I chose this because I believe it is right.”
But did you choose the experiences that gave you those beliefs?
You may say, “I made this decision because of the kind of person I am.”
But did you choose the circumstances that helped create that person?
This does not mean that our choices are imaginary. We clearly experience ourselves thinking, considering and deciding.
The problem is that experiencing a decision does not necessarily mean that we created every force behind it.
Perhaps we are choosing.
But perhaps we are choosing with a mind that was shaped long before we became conscious enough to question it.
**Fate, Destiny and the Strange Question of God's Knowledge
**
Then there is fate.
Or destiny.
Or, for those who believe, God's plan.
This question becomes even more complicated when religion enters the conversation.
Many religious people believe that God is all-knowing. That He knows the beginning and the end. That nothing happens outside divine knowledge.
I once had a conversation with a friend who does not believe in God, and she said something that stayed with me. She said that there is nothing like “God's plan.” According to her, we Christians use the idea of God's plan to mask what she called the illusion of choice, the supposed freedom our God has given to us.
And honestly, that made me think.
Because we Christians are often told that God has a plan for our lives. We are told that He knows us, that He knows what is best for us and that He has a purpose for everything that happens.
But we are also told that we have free will.
So where exactly do the two meet?
If God has a plan for my life, how free am I to create a different one?
If God already knows every decision I will ever make, can I genuinely make a decision He does not already know I will make?
If my entire future is already known to an all-knowing God, is the future truly open to me?
But then I have to ask:
If God already knows everything I will do, can I truly do something else?
If the entire future is already known, where exactly does my freedom begin?
Suppose tomorrow, God already knows that I will make a particular decision. Could I decide otherwise?
But then here's the thing: if I could, then that would mean what God knew would be wrong. But we have always been meant to believe that God is all-powerful...
But if I cannot, then was the decision ever completely open to me?
Now, please, this is not necessarily an argument against God or religion. And I know that if my mother should read this, she would have already planned a family meeting on my behalf. It is simply one of the greatest paradoxes surrounding free will.
But then again, perhaps divine knowledge does not mean divine control. Perhaps God can know a decision without forcing it, just as watching a film for the second time does not cause the characters to act as they do.
But even then, the question remains: if the ending is already known, does the character truly have another possible ending?
Like the case of two plus two being four. Even if you decide to make it three plus one or four plus zero, it will still result in four.
Maybe fate and free will exist together in ways we do not fully understand.
Or perhaps we call something free simply because we cannot see the forces that have already determined it.
And maybe that is the most frightening possibility of all.
What if we are not following a script because someone is physically forcing us to?
What if we are following it because the script has become part of us from the moment we were born?
You Cannot Call Everyone Equally Free
This is another reason I struggle with the idea that everyone has the same freedom.
We love telling people that they can become anything they want if they work hard enough.
It is a beautiful idea.
It is also incomplete.
Imagine two people born on the same day.
One is born into a wealthy family with access to quality education, healthcare, connections and financial security.
The other is born into poverty.
Both may be told:
“You are free to become anything.”
But are they?
Technically, perhaps.
Realistically, not equally.
Freedom is not just about whether someone is legally allowed to do something. It is also about whether they have the conditions to make that possibility real.
A person struggling to survive does not experience freedom in the same way as someone whose basic needs are already guaranteed.
And poverty is not the only limitation.
Culture can limit us.
Family expectations can limit us.
Gender expectations can limit us.
Governments can limit us.
Social class can limit us.
Even other people's opinions can limit us.
A person may technically be free to make a decision while knowing that making that decision could mean losing their family, community, financial support or safety.
So are they really free?
Or are they simply choosing between different forms of loss?
Sometimes we confuse having options with having freedom.
But what kind of freedom is it when every available option carries a punishment?
A bird in a cage may be free to move from one side of the cage to another.
That does not mean the cage has disappeared.
What If the Mind Decides Before We Do?
Then comes an even more uncomfortable question.
What if the conscious “you” is not always the first to make the decision?
We like to imagine that consciousness is the captain of the ship.
That first, we think.
Then, we decide.
Then, we act.
But psychology has shown us something strange about ourselves: we are not always aware of the processes influencing our behaviour.
Sometimes we react before we understand why.
Sometimes we dislike someone before we can explain it.
Sometimes we make decisions emotionally and then use logic to justify them afterwards.
Sometimes we say, “I don't know why I did that.”
And we mean it.
That sentence alone should humble us.
Because how can we claim complete control over ourselves when there are moments when we do not even fully understand ourselves?
Much of what we call “me” exists beneath conscious awareness.
Memories we barely remember can influence us.
Traumas can influence us.
Habits can influence us.
Desires can influence us.
Instincts can influence us.
Our bodies and brains are constantly processing information that we never consciously notice.
So perhaps the conscious mind is not always the author of the decision.
Perhaps sometimes it is simply the narrator.
It arrives after something has already begun and says:
“This is why I did it.”
And perhaps that is one of the greatest illusions of freedom: believing that because we can explain our choices, we were the sole creators of them.
Then Should Anyone Be Held Responsible?
At this point, someone might ask:
“If people are not completely free, then should we hold anyone responsible for anything?”
It is a fair question.
If a person's behaviour is shaped by their genes, childhood, environment and experiences, does that mean they should be excused for everything they do?
I do not think so.
Understanding why someone did something is not the same as saying that what they did was acceptable.
But I do think the limits of free will should make us more careful about how we judge people.
We are often too quick to look at someone's life and assume that we know why they are where they are.
We see someone struggling and say they made bad choices.
We see someone successful and say they made good choices.
But we rarely see the thousands of invisible circumstances behind either life.
The truth is that responsibility and circumstance can exist together.
A person can be responsible for their actions while also being shaped by things they never chose.
Society still needs laws. People still need to be accountable. Harm still has consequences.
But perhaps accountability should not mean pretending that human beings exist outside cause and circumstance.
Justice should ask:
“What did you do?”
But it should also ask:
“Why did you do it?”
Not because every explanation is an excuse.
But because understanding a person is sometimes the beginning of preventing the same harm from happening again.
A society that believes entirely in free will can become cruel.
It can blame people for every condition of their lives.
But a society that believes people have no agency at all can become hopeless.
It can convince individuals that nothing they do matters.
Perhaps the truth lies somewhere between cruelty and hopelessness.
So, Are We Free?
After thinking about all this, I cannot honestly say that we are completely free.
We did not choose our beginnings.
We did not choose our genes.
We did not choose the family that first taught us how to see the world.
We did not choose many of the experiences that created our fears and desires.
We do not completely control the unconscious processes occurring inside our minds.
We cannot always escape the limits imposed by poverty, society, culture or circumstance.
And for those who believe in destiny or an all-knowing God, there remains the question of whether a future that is already known can ever be completely open.
So, no.
I do not think we are free in the absolute sense.
We cannot choose what decisions to make without thinking of society's expectations and reactions to them.
We cannot choose who we are, or who we love, who we should love, or who we can and should be.
But I also do not think we are puppets.
And perhaps this is where the most honest understanding of free will lies.
We are neither completely controlled nor completely independent.
We are shaped, but we can respond to what shapes us.
We are influenced, but we can become aware of those influences.
We inherit beliefs, but we can question them. Please, for Christ's sake, questions do a lot of good. It doesn't automatically mean rebellion.
We carry wounds, but we can refuse to let those wounds make every decision for us.
We cannot always choose what happens to us.
But sometimes, we can choose what we do next.
And perhaps that is what freedom really is.
Not the ability to exist without limits.
Not the ability to control everything.
Not the fantasy of being completely untouched by the world.
Perhaps freedom is the ability to become conscious of the invisible forces shaping us and, within whatever space remains, decide what we will do with them.
We may not have written the script.
We may not even be able to see all of it.
Some lines were given to us by history.
Some by biology.
Some by our families.
Some by society.
Some by experiences we would never have chosen.
But somewhere between the line we were given and the line we speak next, there is a pause.
A small space.
A moment in which we can reflect.
Question.
Resist.
Change.
Choose.
Maybe that space is smaller than we like to admit.
Maybe our freedom has limits we cannot see.
But perhaps it is in that small space that our humanity lives.
We are not completely free.
We are not completely bound.
We are free within limits.
Free within circumstances.
Free within a life that began without our permission.
Perhaps we are following a script we cannot completely see.
But perhaps freedom was never about writing the entire script.
Perhaps freedom is about what we do when we finally realise that we are in one.
But oh well, we can never truly know, can we?
Loading the full page…