ARTICLE · LEARNING · 4 MIN READ

Maybe We Have Been Measuring Intelligence Wrong

The World Cup is on, and yesterday I found myself watching a match and wondering how goalkeepers do what they do.

Think about it. A goalkeeper's hands, when stretched out, can only cover a small section of the goal. Yet they are expected to defend an entire goalpost. I remember trying to be a goalkeeper when I was younger. Wueh. I saw dust. The only way I became a good goalkeeper was by making the goalposts smaller. Problem solved.

But these professional goalkeepers somehow manage to stop balls travelling at crazy speeds. They dive before the ball even arrives. Sometimes they even seem to know where the striker will shoot before the striker himself has decided.

Then there are the players.

One player can be somewhere near the halfway line and send a pass to a teammate who is running twenty metres away. Not where the teammate is, but where he is going to be. The ball lands exactly where it should.

I have watched football my whole life, but when I stop and think about it, that thing makes no sense.

How do they know?

Back in the village, I had a friend called Mutiso.

Mutiso always knew where the ball would land. Long passes, rebounds, crosses, anything. Before the rest of us figured out what was happening, Mutiso was already there waiting for the ball.

A neighbouring team once accused him of using juju. Looking back, I can't even blame them.

Then there was Kaloki, our goalkeeper. If the ball was round, chances are it wasn't getting past him. The man had some sort of relationship with footballs that the rest of us could not understand.

The funny thing is that neither Mutiso nor Kaloki would have been considered the smartest students in school.

At least not according to the standards we used.

Growing up, many of us were taught that the brightest students were the ones who excelled in Mathematics and Science. Those were the students who got called to the front of the class. Those were the students teachers used as examples.

I was actually one of those students. Nowadays, I ask ChatGPT what 1 + 8 is, but that's a discussion for another day.

The thing that puzzles me is that, despite doing well in Mathematics and Science, I could never do what Mutiso did on a football field.

I couldn't predict where the ball would land. I couldn't read the game. I couldn't calculate movement, speed, angles, and timing while twenty-two people were running around.

Mutiso could.

Kaloki could.

And many others can.

So what exactly were we measuring in school?

Because from where I stand, these guys were doing Mathematics and Physics every weekend. They just weren't doing it with a pen and paper.

To receive a pass properly, your brain has to estimate speed, distance, and direction. To intercept a ball, you have to predict movement. To strike a ball accurately, you have to understand angles and force, whether you call it Physics or not.

The calculations are still happening.

The intelligence is still there.

It is simply showing itself differently.

This is why I sometimes feel the education system has been unfair to many people. Not because Mathematics and Science are bad subjects. Far from it. The problem is that we often mistake one way of demonstrating intelligence for intelligence itself.

Some people understand the world through numbers.

Others understand it through movement.

Some through music.

Some through storytelling.

Some through building things.

Some through bringing people together.

Yet we have spent years acting as if only one of those abilities deserves to be called intelligence.

Maybe that is why so many talented people end up believing they are not smart enough.

Maybe that is why some people spend their lives trying to fit into systems that were never designed to recognise their strengths.

I am not saying exams should disappear. I am simply saying that being "sharp" is much bigger than passing a paper.

If intelligence is the ability to understand and interact with the world around us, then I have met plenty of geniuses who never topped a class.

Mutiso might be one of them.

Back to top ↑

Loading the full page…