ARTICLE · WRITING · 7 MIN READ
Life by the Lake
A story about the inspirational Sue Carter and the changes she made in the city of Toledo.

The lake is beautiful.
Sue Carter sits on her porch, surrounded by her garden and nearly dozing off to the sounds of the waves hitting the rocky shore. A cat wanders beneath her porch swing, meowing up at her. She smiles. She is remembering things. Her life. Her victories. Her mother, maybe most of all. The big things. The little things. Her life has been big, that’s certain.
Her husband, Mike Ferner, comes to sit beside her, a Labbott Blue Beer in his hand as there always is to watch the sunset. He pops it open, tossing the cap in the plants. When the little neighbor girls visit, they love to scour the garden, finding the bottlecaps and collecting them for arts and crafts. Mike and Sue live in a cozy little house on a cozy little street in the big city of Toledo, a jewel buried just between the skyscrapers and Lake Erie.
They gaze together at the garden, which Sue devotes hours to tending. It’s completely native, full of lilies and tulips and daffodils and irises, colors beyond a simple rainbow. It’s a cacophony of flowers, a magical sight for anyone who sees it.
Sue thinks of her mother, of the lessons she taught her. She likes to think of her, of who Sue may have become if her mother were different. If she hadn’t cared so much about equality. If she hadn’t shown Sue that you don’t need to believe what other people tell you.
Sue remembers everyone in her life. The people she helped, in her years as an HIV counselor. The people she couldn’t help. The people she fought for, as a rights activist. The people she loved, her husband, her friends, her family.
She remembers her years as president of ACLU Ohio board of directors. She remembers fighting for women, and for LGBTQIA+ rights, and for Mother Nature herself. She recalls defending her friends, and missing them dearly as they pass on. She thinks of protests and rallies she attended, banners she made and buttons she wore. Words she spoke, changes she made.
Sue smiles.
She first discovered her desire to fight for people when she worked at Sears Roebuck, being the singular woman while her coworkers were all men, many of whom were gay. She became close friends with them, learning more about the difficult life of a gay man in the 80s. Sue had known it wasn’t easy, but having those people in her life helped her to learn that she didn’t just want to fight for what affected her, but she wanted to help those like her friends, even though she wasn’t a part of that community.
After Sue’s boss passed suddenly from HIV, Sue was asked to take his place, becoming the first female head of department in Sears history. The department didn’t know what to do with her. They told her she didn’t need to stay up late or be up early for events, they tried to pamper her. But Sue only told them, “I’ll be there.”
After working at the department store for quite some time, Sue realized that the company was trying to make unwanted workers, such as women or older individuals, quit. Rather than fire them, Sue found they were being bullied off the team. She thought of her mother, of the hard work that she’s already done. And Sue decided that if they were going to get rid of her, they would have to fire her, straight out. But she refused to quit.
She was bullied for a long time, until she decided she didn’t need to put up with it. She got herself a lawyer, a tape recorder, and set to work. She didn’t hide. She didn’t ask someone to do it for her. Sue sat down with her boss and told them that what they were doing was discrimination, and she would not stand for it.
She was right, and the company knew it. Sue didn’t continue working at the company, of her own accord, but she did convince them to stop their discrimination. And she now knows leaving that company was one of the best decisions she made.
Sue knew she was going to help people, but not just with social issues. She returned to school and became an AIDS/HIV counselor, helping to care for and support people who were fighting through the AIDS crisis. The world needed help, and not enough citizens were willing to rise up and be the change. Luckily, Sue was.
During her work as a counselor, Sue joined the ACLU (American Civil Liberties Union) Of Ohio Board of Directors. Just like her mother, Sue cared about the world and wanted to make it better. Though her mother was never a protester, she raised her children to become what she could not. And Sue was not going to let her down. She served on the board for 25 years, being the board’s president for 10 of them.
Sue was living in Toledo at the time, in a cozy little apartment. It may have been big enough for Sue, but not for her . . . and all her cats. A friend inspired her to buy a house on the lake, and Sue loved the idea. Unfortunately, at the time, women couldn’t be homeowners. She would have needed a father or a husband to cosign with her for the purchase. It was just another example of how unfairly women have been treated, as recently as the 70s. And Sue wouldn’t stand for it. She was married at the time, but she refused to rely on somebody else for a right she knew belonged to her. Sue was going to buy the house under her own name, no exceptions.
And that’s exactly what she did. She found a bank that was hoping to be more progressive, one that was willing to sell her the house. However, Sue didn’t quite have the money for it. So, she beat the system. Using a loan from a different bank, Sue made the down payment, buying the beautiful house on the lake where she still lives to this day. Sue didn’t know it then, but allowing herself the independence of owning her own home was the greatest decision she ever made.
Sue always stood up for people. For women, for members of the LGBTQ+ community, for people of color, for elderly or disabled people. But Sue didn’t only protect others. She stood up for herself when she needed to. At a party for the Toledo Animal Shelter, the Toledo Blade Newspaper came and took photos. Sue was included in a photo, and they needed a name for the caption.
“My name is Sue Carter,” She had said, but the reporters didn’t want to know that. They wanted to know her husband’s name.
“My husband is Mr. George, and I am Sue Carter.” At the time, reporters would only write a woman’s name as Mrs. Husband. But Sue was not Sue George, she was Sue Carter, a name that she would not so easily give up.
The reporter was hesitant, but Sue didn’t quit. She refused to have her picture included unless it was her real name beside it. And the plan worked. Sue Carter became the first married woman in the Toledo Blade whose name was her own, not that of her husband. She made her own way. She found her own identity. And she stood by it.
Sue sits on the porch, watching the gulls fly above the lake and the fisherman search for the perfect spot. She admires her garden, full of native plants which flourish under her care. She smiles at her cats, who all wander in the grass, catching bugs beneath their paws and meowing at the squirrels in the trees. She thinks of her life, her big life in a big city with a legacy she hoped would be big, although who can tell what happens to you when you’re not there anymore. Who tells your story, if anyone does.
She takes a deep breath, feeling the fresh air glide through her body, making her grateful again for the beautiful house she bought so long ago. Her husband sits down beside her, smiling as a cat leaps up to share the swing with them. Of course, Sue hasn’t stopped. She still protests, still fights for the rights of those around her. She still works to protect those who can’t protect themselves, still fights for equality and justice in her town.
But here, today, on this porch with her love and her flowers and her cats, she lives in the moment. She admires the beauty of Glass City Toledo. She smiles.
AUTHOR’S NOTE
Thanks for reading! Sue Carter was my neighbor growing up. Remember the little girls who searched the garden for bottle caps? That’s me. I saw this contest and thought of her. I called her to make sure my facts were correct, then wrote! Hope you enjoy!
Loading the full page…